In East of England Ambulance Service NHS Trust v Sanders the EAT has held that a tribunal committed a procedural error in searching on the internet for evidence that supported a claimant’s case that she was disabled, and in relying on that evidence in its conclusions. The tribunal thereby gave the impression of bias against the respondent employer. This was compounded by the tribunal preventing forensic cross-examination of the witness claiming to be disabled and itself asking leading questions.
As an aside, Mr Justice Langstaff, President of the EAT, went on to raise a seemingly novel procedural issue. He pointed out that the bundle of authorities contained no marking of the passages that were to be relied upon.
Langstaff P warned that, in future, a party who turns up to pursue an appeal wishing to rely upon an unmarked bundle may be required to mark all the bundles before the case begins, and must be prepared to give sufficient time to the other side, especially if a litigant in person, to consider those passages. If this gives rise to a risk of the matter being part-heard or adjourned when it would not otherwise have been, then that party must be prepared to defend any resulting costs application.
EAT judgment
www.charlesprice.net
Thursday, 13 November 2014
Monday, 10 November 2014
Employment tribunal decides attendance at union meetings is not 'working time'
Xperthr.co.uk reported this week that an employment tribunal found that attendance at union meetings is not "working time". Unfortunately this was not an EAT case but still interesting:
Edwards v Encirc Ltd ET/2412489/2013
Two trade union representatives working night shifts claimed that the time they spent attending union meetings during the day was "working time" and so they were entitled to an 11-hour rest period from the end of the meetings until the start of their next night shift. The employment tribunal rejected this claim.... report
www.charlesprice.net
Edwards v Encirc Ltd ET/2412489/2013
Two trade union representatives working night shifts claimed that the time they spent attending union meetings during the day was "working time" and so they were entitled to an 11-hour rest period from the end of the meetings until the start of their next night shift. The employment tribunal rejected this claim.... report
www.charlesprice.net
Tuesday, 4 November 2014
Overtime and holiday pay - Bear Scotland v Fulton (and conjoined cases) a filip for beleagured employees
Employers should be aware that under the Working Time Regulations 1998, every employee is entitled to 20 days paid holiday a year, i.e. 4 weeks. Holiday pay is calculated on the basis of an employees normal working hours. For example, if you work a 35-hour week, then your holiday pay is based on 35 hours. However, if you are guaranteed 5 hours overtime each week, then holiday pay is calculated on the basis that your normal working hours are 40 hours week.
What happens if you work on average 5 hours overtime each week but it is not guaranteed? Up until recently, it would not have counted when calculating holiday pay. The judgment highlighted today has changed this although its auspices to not extend to not the additional 1.6 weeks under regulation 13A of the Working Time Regulations.
In April 2013, the Birmingham Employment Tribunal considered this issue in the case of Neal –v– Freightliner Ltd. It decided that Mr Neal's holiday pay should have been calculated by reference to his normal earnings, which included overtime and shift pay. The Employment Tribunal ordered Freightliner Ltd to pay Mr Neal additional holiday pay based on his overtime and shift pay.
Later in the same month, the Glasgow Employment Tribunal in the case of Fulton & Baxter –v– Bear Scotland Ltd followed the Neal decision
The Employment Appeal Tribunal has, today given judgment in Bear Scotland v Fulton (and conjoined cases).
There was a real fear prior to the promulgation of this judgment that employees may be able to claim there has been a chain of unlawful deductions in relation to EU statutory holiday pay. That could mean they can claim back-pay going as far back as 1998, potentially including interest as well. Further, employees and ex-employees may attempt to recover back-pay by bringing a breach of contract claim. The issue of back-pay has even led to speculation that some employers may be forced out of business.s reaffirmed that workers are entitled to be paid a sum of money to reflect normal non-guaranteed overtime as part of their annual leave payments. Claims for arrears of holiday pay will be out of time however if there has been a break of more than three months between successive underpayments (subject to the usual 'reasonable practicability test').
In addition travel time payments, which exceed expenses incurred and so amount to additional taxable remuneration, also count when calculating holiday pay.
The government has set up a task force to look into the impact of the ruling on businesses.
www.charlesprice.net
.
Monday, 3 November 2014
The UK employment laws all UK businesses should know about - guest post
If the Conservatives win the next General Election, David Cameron has promised a referendum over Britain’s future in the European Union by the end of 2017. This has called into question what changes could be made to UK employment law.
If Britain does choose to remain in the EU and Cameron is
able to successfully renegotiate the terms of Britain’s inclusion, which laws
could be altered?
It is vital that all employers understand the current laws
that might be altered, especially smaller businesses without corporate support.
Here are a few of the current British employment laws linked to EU regulations.
The Working Time Regulations Act 1998
The Working Time Regulations Act 1998 supports the EU Working Time Directive and is the means
by which UK break times and weekly working hours are monitored. The act
dictates that:
·
Workers must work no more than 48 hours per
week.
·
The mandatory right to annual paid leave is a
minimum of 28 days, including public holidays.
·
The right to a minimum rest period of 20 minutes
for any shift lasting 6 or more hours.
TUPE (Transfer of Undertakings Protection of Employment)
Regulations 2006
TUPE defends employees from changes that could occur when a
business is sold or taken over. This protects from changes made by both the
outgoing employer and the new employer taking control.
The Part Time Employees Act 2000
The Part Time Employees Regulations act of 2000 exists to
assure that all employees working shorter hours are given rights and privileges
equivalent to their full time peers.
The Agency Workers Regulations Act 2010
The Agency Workers act is in place to ensure that agency
workers employed by UK businesses receive the same treatment as permanently
employed staff.
Paid Parental Leave Act 2010
This act ensures that employees taking time out from work
for childcare purposes are provided with paid leave, holiday allowances and the
right to return to their job when the agreed period is over.
Equal Pay rights under The Equality Act of 2010.
The
equality act ensures equal pay is granted to all employees performing the same
job. This covers women’s right to earn the same as men, and gives self-employed workers the same rights as corporately
employed employees. This law caters for:
·
Full and part-time workers
·
Employees on casual or temporary
contracts
·
Apprentices
Various EU laws have caused disagreements between EU member
states due to political, social and economic differences. This can be seen in
Britain’s numerous attempts to block certain EU employment legislation and
delay introduction of these laws.
Conservative plans to alter Britain’s dependence on EU law
has led the Trade Union Congress to challenge Tory intentions, alleging they
want certain laws to correspond with conservative agenda. The acts most
frequently accused of being manipulated are the Agency Workers Regulations and
Working Time Regulations acts.
Would you like to see Britain move away from EU employment
legislation? Comment and let us know.
This blog was submitted on behalf of Nationwide Employment
Lawyers; an expert UK law firm specialising in all areas of employment law.
Visit their website for details: http://natemplaw.co.uk
Please note that whilst every
effort is made to maintain accuracy of the content in this article; we cannot
take responsibility for any errors. This author is not an Employment Lawyer or
HR Specialist and this cannot in any way constitute a substitute for Employment
Law advice. All facts should be cross-checked against other sources. Should you
require specific Employment Law advice, then we recommend that you contact
Nationwide Employment Lawyers.
Monday, 27 October 2014
Equal Pay case tests equal job evaluation in the private sector
Asda are being pursued by the employment lawyers Leigh Day who two years ago won a landmark £1bn supreme court ruling for lower-paid women employed by Birmingham city council.
If pay discrepancies in equal value jobs can be proved, other supermarkets and retailers, such as Tesco, Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Marks & Spencer and John Lewis, could face similar claims. The Asda cases will determine if the supermarket's store staff jobs, which are mainly held by female workers, are of equal value to higher-paid jobs in the company's male-dominated distribution centres. If they win, workers could be entitled to six years' back pay for the difference in earnings.
Until now equal job evaluation has mainly affected local councils, where jobs are assessed and given pay grades. Birmingham alone has so far paid around half of its £1.1bn bill for the back pay settlements to the women – including cleaners, cooks, care workers and school lunch supervisors – who were denied bonuses and attendance allowances given to male road cleaners and refuse collectors.
The Asda parity issue is expected to be heard within the next two months at Manchester employment tribunal. Newman said Leigh Day was representing 414 store staff, most though not all women.
Asda said in a statement: "We are aware of a small number of claims. We pay a fair market rate for the job people do regardless of gender and we don't recognise discrimination in our business."
The precedent for equal pay claims for comparable jobs was set in 1997 when 1,500 Cleveland dinner ladies won a £5m payout.
A national single status agreement was drawn up the same year giving local authorities 10 years to introduce fair and non-discriminatory grading structures. Tens of thousands of mainly female workers in such jobs, however, are still awaiting settlements for back pay. The general and public service unions GMB and Unison said they had 40,000 outstanding cases across the UK, including in Birmingham.
Statistics show 37,400 equal pay cases were brought in 2009-10, 34,600 in 2010-11 and 28,800 in 2011-12.
www.charlesprice.net
If pay discrepancies in equal value jobs can be proved, other supermarkets and retailers, such as Tesco, Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Marks & Spencer and John Lewis, could face similar claims. The Asda cases will determine if the supermarket's store staff jobs, which are mainly held by female workers, are of equal value to higher-paid jobs in the company's male-dominated distribution centres. If they win, workers could be entitled to six years' back pay for the difference in earnings.
Until now equal job evaluation has mainly affected local councils, where jobs are assessed and given pay grades. Birmingham alone has so far paid around half of its £1.1bn bill for the back pay settlements to the women – including cleaners, cooks, care workers and school lunch supervisors – who were denied bonuses and attendance allowances given to male road cleaners and refuse collectors.
The Asda parity issue is expected to be heard within the next two months at Manchester employment tribunal. Newman said Leigh Day was representing 414 store staff, most though not all women.
Asda said in a statement: "We are aware of a small number of claims. We pay a fair market rate for the job people do regardless of gender and we don't recognise discrimination in our business."
The precedent for equal pay claims for comparable jobs was set in 1997 when 1,500 Cleveland dinner ladies won a £5m payout.
A national single status agreement was drawn up the same year giving local authorities 10 years to introduce fair and non-discriminatory grading structures. Tens of thousands of mainly female workers in such jobs, however, are still awaiting settlements for back pay. The general and public service unions GMB and Unison said they had 40,000 outstanding cases across the UK, including in Birmingham.
Statistics show 37,400 equal pay cases were brought in 2009-10, 34,600 in 2010-11 and 28,800 in 2011-12.
www.charlesprice.net
Friday, 17 October 2014
Claim rejected for non-compliance with early conciliation rules but then allowed in under Rule 13(4)
In Thomas v Nationwide Building Society (Cardiff Employment Tribunal Case No. 1601342/2014) an employment judge has rejected a claim for failure to comply with the early conciliation procedure. One of the first reported cases!
T presented a claim of whistleblowing detriment on 8 August 2014. Such a claim is subject to the early conciliation (EC) procedure established by Ss.18A-18C of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996, by which any would-be claimant must first contact Acas with details of the claim, and receive a certificate confirming completion of the EC procedure, before instituting tribunal proceedings. Failure to do so means that the tribunal has no jurisdiction to hear the claim.
The Claimant argued that she could comply with the procedure retroactively and have the rejection of her claim reconsidered under rule 13(4) of the Employment Tribunal Rules of Procedure 2013, which allows for a rejected claim to be accepted if the rejection was based on a defect that has since been rectified.
Employment Judge Clarke ruled that non-compliance with the EC procedure was a ‘defect’ capable of being rectified so as to allow for reconsideration under rule 13. In the judge’s view, even late compliance with the conciliation procedure would still be ‘pre-claim’, given that the original claim had been rejected. The effect of rule 13 is that the claim can proceed once the defect has been rectified, albeit that it will be treated as having been presented on the date of such rectification. He also rejected the suggestion that T would have to present a fresh ET1 once she had completed the EC procedure.
It must be noted that this was heard only in the ET and therefore we wait to see if it will go upstairs.
Cardiff Employment Tribunal
Charles Price Barrister
T presented a claim of whistleblowing detriment on 8 August 2014. Such a claim is subject to the early conciliation (EC) procedure established by Ss.18A-18C of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996, by which any would-be claimant must first contact Acas with details of the claim, and receive a certificate confirming completion of the EC procedure, before instituting tribunal proceedings. Failure to do so means that the tribunal has no jurisdiction to hear the claim.
The Claimant argued that she could comply with the procedure retroactively and have the rejection of her claim reconsidered under rule 13(4) of the Employment Tribunal Rules of Procedure 2013, which allows for a rejected claim to be accepted if the rejection was based on a defect that has since been rectified.
Employment Judge Clarke ruled that non-compliance with the EC procedure was a ‘defect’ capable of being rectified so as to allow for reconsideration under rule 13. In the judge’s view, even late compliance with the conciliation procedure would still be ‘pre-claim’, given that the original claim had been rejected. The effect of rule 13 is that the claim can proceed once the defect has been rectified, albeit that it will be treated as having been presented on the date of such rectification. He also rejected the suggestion that T would have to present a fresh ET1 once she had completed the EC procedure.
It must be noted that this was heard only in the ET and therefore we wait to see if it will go upstairs.
Cardiff Employment Tribunal
Charles Price Barrister
Thursday, 16 October 2014
Update your employment policies ACAS guidance on shared parental leave and ante-natal appointments
ACAS has published a detailed guidance note on the new shared parental leave rules.
Key Points are listed as follows:
'Employed mothers will continue to be entitled to 52 weeks of Maternity Leave and 39 weeks of statutory maternity pay or maternity allowance
If they choose to do so, an eligible mother can end her maternity leave early and, with her partner or the child's father, will be able to opt for Shared Parental Leave instead of Maternity Leave. If they both meet the qualifying requirements and both qualify, they will need to decide how they divide their total Shared Parental Leave and Pay entitlement between them
Paid Paternity Leave of two weeks will continue to be available to fathers and a mother's or adopter's partners
Adopters will have the same rights as other parents to Shared Parental leave and pay
Intended parents in surrogacy who meet certain criteria will be eligible for statutory adoption leave and pay and Shared Parental Leave and Pay'
Please also remember when updating your Maternity/Paternity policies that From 1 October 2014 expectant fathers, or the partner of a pregnant woman, will be entitled to take unpaid time off work to attend antenatal appointments with their partner. The Department of Business, Innovation and Skills has produced a guide for employers (which works equally well for employees).
Employees accompanying the expectant mother to her ante-natal appointments are entitled to unpaid leave for 1 or 2 appointments. The time off is capped at six and a half hours for each appointment.
The Government is aiming to achieve greater involvement of both of the child’s parents from the earliest stages of pregnancy.
An employer is not entitled to ask for any evidence of the ante-natal appointments, such as an appointment card, as this is the property of the expectant mother attending the appointment.
However, an employer is entitled to ask the employee for a declaration stating the date and time of the appointment, that the employee qualifies for the unpaid time off through his or her relationship with the mother or child, and that the time off is for the purpose of attending an ante-natal appointment with the expectant mother that has been made on the advice of a registered medical practitioner, nurse or midwife.
Charles Price is a Direct Access Barrister with 15 years experience 07846692325
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)